There are 11 reasons that football is better than football. Or, football is better than American football. Or, even still, Soccer is better than American football. Why 11? Well, that’s an odd, obscure, uneven number. And there are 11 men on a soccer pitch.
1. The Name Makes Sense
In football, they actually use their foot to kick a ball.
By now you’ve all seen the ‘football – Handegg’ picture (and if you haven’t, I’ve included it reference). There isn’t really much more that needs to be said is there? Why call something ‘football’ if you rarely kick it and the ball is not even spherical? Frankly, the name of ‘football’ to describe soccer is just more correct. Thus, it’s wayyyy better.

I think HandEgg is a great alternative name for American football. First step, rename the NFL to the NHL. Wait, that’s taken by another sport that is equally better than American football… damn. I guess ThrowEgg could work, and then the organization would be the NTL. Yeah!
Football’s origins are found in the term ‘Association football’, meaning an association of groups of teams that play football. The popular sport of the 1800′s was an Americanized version of rugby and association football, what we know today as American Football. Thus the American association football players came up with the term ‘soccer’, using the ‘soc’ part of association. It’s a stretch, I know.
2. Length of a Game
In football, the game is composed of two halves of 45 minutes with a 15 minute halftime break. Depending on injuries and other downtime, there can be a couple of minutes here and there added to the end of the halves at the referee’s discretion. In rare situations like single elimination cup tournaments, extra time can also be added in the result of a tie game. Thus, far more often than not, the length of a football game is clear from the outset.
In American football, there is absolutely no way to predict how long a game is going to last! Although it’s very clearly stated there there are four 15 minute quarters with a 12 minute halftime, the game never actually lasts that long. There are far too many occasions in which the clock stops, thus adding on to the total length of the game. In fact, the average broadcast of an NFL game is 174 minutes! Yeah, that’s right, almost 3 hours long for a regulation 75 minute game.
A sport that has a clearly set length of play that is adhered to is surely more accessible and fun to watch than one that is not. Hooray football! And that also brings us to the fact that there is also more actual playtime in football…
3. Actual Play Time

American football is notorious for its small quantity of actual playtime. A Wall Street Journal study from January of 2010 summarized that American football only has on average 11 minutes of actual playtime. 11 minutes! In a 3 hour broadcast there are 11 minutes of actual playtime? What sort of a sport is this! There is probably more playtime in a round of bowling. In fact, on average 59% of an NFL broadcast is footage of the players standing around and 15% of the footage is just replays.
Although there are throw-ins and free kicks and injuries in football, there is far, far more playtime. Actually, it’s approximately 90 minutes worth since the game length and continuous nature of play makes sense! So not only is the length of the game slightly less, but there is actually more playtime.
Why watch a 3 hour game with 11 minutes of playtime when you could watch a 2 hour game with 90 minutes of playtime? WHYYYY!?
4. Continuous Play
Every time something happens in American Football, the game stops. Then something happens again, and then it stops again. There’s this little notion of a ‘down’ in which the teams and players regroup and formulate a plan to start the play again. This causes a start-stop, start-stop play style. There is just no way around it: there is a lot of downtime in American football (hey check out that pun).
In football the play is continuous. Like I already mentioned, throw-ins, free kicks, and injuries do happen and they do require a stoppage in play. However, play always resumes quickly and the frequency of these stops pales in comparison to the stoppages in American football. IT PALES!
Part of the reason for all the stoppages in American football is to allow for the league to air advertisements. The league is a business and as a result it has taken steps to alter the rules of the game to allow for proper time for advertising. Us American audiences have very short attention spans so the NFL has taken all the steps it can to show us all the advertisements, replays, flashy graphics, and commentary possible.
Football wins again, because it isn’t plagued with constant interruptions, speculation, advertising, and standing around.
5. Better Strategy
The strategy of both games is complex. And in all honesty, it’s pretty difficult to compare the strategies of these two games, but guess what? I still think football’s is deeper.
Football is a non-stop fluid game that requires quick thinking and strategy from every player on the field at all times. The manager acts as an orchestra director by choosing the right players for the right games over the entirety of the season, making choice substitutions where appropriate, and simultaneously juggling the recruitment of new players and the training of the existing ones.
There are set plays but generally speaking the game requires the players to adjust and react to any situation that may arise at any time. A left back may see a good opportunity and charge down the left side of the pitch, which will require a shift from the other defenders and perhaps a midfielder to cover when the play shifts back towards them. Football players must be capable at all aspects of the game.

American football is more like a live human version of chess. Generally speaking, it is the coach, his staff, and the quarterback that discuss and choose plays for the rest of the team to execute. At that point, the players typically act like pawns as each one must perform his own actions as best he can. Granted, there are often situations in which players must think on their feet within the frame of the play, but more often than not they are carrying out a task as best they can. Then the play ends.
Although chess is as strategic a game as you can get, imagine playing a variant of it where there are no turns. Although there is a player (coach), the individual pieces must also act together out of their own accord, swapping roles and responsibilities on the fly. Football requires in depth strategy and skill from the managers and the players, more-so than American Football.
6. More Competition
Simply put, football is the world’s game. As of right now there are 208 countries in FIFA, the governing organization of football. That’s a lot of different leagues, players, and teams. As best I can find, there are only about 40 countries that have American football leagues. Since football (soccer) has a bigger worldwide presence, the competition is more intense. Every country, every league, every team, and every player must compete against each other to be the best they can be.
Let’s take the UEFA Champion’s League for example. This league, the height of club football, features the best teams from the best leagues within Europe. They play against each other in international battles over the period of several months while they play within their own domestic leagues. At the end of it all, you have a winner who is crowned the best team in all of Europe. One year it may be Inter Milan, while the next it could be Barcelona. Hell, there is even a league ‘below’ the Champion’s League called the Europa League, which follows the same format.
The recent introduction of the FIFA Club World Cup now means that the winners of the different world region’s “Champion’s Leagues” all play against each other to be the best club in the world. Even the LA Galaxy has reason to compete at a top level… they could face a club like Arsenal or Chelsea in the Club World Cup someday.
American Football doesn’t have the same worldwide scale that football does. This means that the cream of the crop resides firmly in the United States. Although there are an increasing number of foreign players in the NFL, an overwhelming percentage of its players are American. Foreign leagues are still in their infancy and have fewer teams.
You simply can’t argue against the worldwide competition that football has. Worldwide competition ultimately means that there is more competition. That’s another reason football is better than American football.
7. Season Schedule & Structure
FIFA, a global organization, has been around since 1904, a 16 year head start on the NFL, which is a national organization. FIFA has promoted a very structured system for the way in which football is organized. Countries have leagues, or even ladders of leagues, and in those leagues the teams play each other in a calculated manner. Generally speaking, such as in the English Premier League, each team plays each other twice, once home and once away. Each team is awarded points based upon the result of the games they play. At the end of the season one team is at the top of the table. This means every game matters. Every game matters. Simple, right?
In the NFL, there is a bizarre system of play in which teams may or may not even play each other, and some teams may end up playing each other twice. Just check out these scheduling rules courtesy of Wikipedia:
- Each team plays the other three teams in its division twice: once at home, and once on the road (six games).
- Each team plays the four teams from another division within its own conference once on a rotating three-year cycle: two at home, and two on the road (four games).
- Each team plays the four teams from a division in the other conference once on a rotating four-year cycle: two at home, and two on the road (four games).
- Each team plays once against the other teams in its conference that finished in the same place in their own divisions as themselves the previous season, not counting the division they were already scheduled to play: one at home, one on the road (two games).
WHAT?! THAT IS RIDICULOUS. There is no consistency season to season AT ALL!
In addition, in countries like England, rich in football culture, that have a ladder system of several leagues atop each other. At the end of each season, the top teams from one league can be promoted to the league above it, and likewise the teams at the bottom can go down! This makes for an extremely competitive league system in which money, glory, and fame are all constantly at stake.
Although there are several different American football leagues in the United States, there is not a promotion/relegation system like other countries, and the US is the only country with multiple leagues.
8. Scoring Systems
American football has a straightforward system of scoring… if you’ve been watching and playing it all your life. Simply put, the way in which teams accrue points in American football is bewildering. Here’s a reference for those of you that aren’t in the know.
- 6 – Touchdown
- 3 – Field Goal
- 2 – Two-point conversion
- 1 – Field Goal
- 2 – Safety
And let’s not forget that there are special circumstances as to when you can get actually score certain points…
In football, there is a goal. When the ball goes into the opposing team’s goal, the scoring team get’s a goal. Done.
9. Skill
Don’t get me wrong, I do think that American football players are skilled. Quarterbacks can throw a perfectly timed pass at the right trajectory so that a wide receiver can make a leaping dive, dragging his foot along the turf just before he falls out of bounds. The way defensive players must pace themselves and apply coverage is equally impressive. That’s skill all around.
In football (soccer) though, I believe players have to be more versatile and practice their skill over longer periods of time. Thus, they are more skilled.
A football (soccer) player, regardless of his position on the field, must be capable of playing offensively and defensively, he must be able to pass and shoot, and he must be able to cover and play off the ball. In addition, he must do all of those things consecutively for the entire game with rapid changes taking place at all times.
In American football, a player typically has one task that he must do for one down, and then repeat. Granted, the way in which a player acts changes from down to down depending on the play and the circumstances that come up. But, for example, a quarterback doesn’t have to fend off multiple rushes for 10 minutes straight while throwing a ball, catching a ball, and then switch gears to then play defense. For that matter, no player in any position has to do anything like that. The game just isn’t set up like that.
The skill involved in soccer is broader, requires more study and practice, and is more impressive to watch.
10. Frequency of Play
Most football leagues play more games more frequently than American football leagues. In Spain for example, a team could be playing in the domestic league (La Liga), the league cup (Copa del Rey), and the regional cup (Champion’s League/Europa League) all at the same time. It’s possible for the total game count for a team to reach upwards of 50 games in a good season, often requiring the team to play two games in one week. This isn’t possible in every football league, but it is possible and does frequently occur in the most popular and successful leagues.
In the NFL, games are spaced out so that there is only one game a week over the period of 17 weeks. Then after that there are 4 more weeks of playoffs, spaced out over 2 months… 2 months! Then the season is over. That’s it! Although the games are big, they are not frequent.
More games, longer season, better sport.
11. Viewership
For the first time in the history of the competition the Champion’s League Final viewership eclipsed the Superbowl viewership in 2009, 206 million to 162 million. And don’t even get me started on the World Cup final, which I think is actually an unfair comparison since it occurs every 4 years. Simply put, football is better because there are more people watching it than there are people watching American football. If put to a vote, the world would agree. It’s unanimous!
Reasons Why American Football is Better
There’s less diving (or feigning of injury), there are video replays, and they have cheerleaders. I won’t bother to elaborate more because it just isn’t enough.
(Real) Football Wins!
Some Sources:
Wikipedia – American Football
Wikipedia – Association Football
WSJ – 11 Minutes of Action
Wikipedia – List of FIFA Members
Wikipedia – List of Countries with American Football Leagues
Wikipedia – NFL on Television
NYTimes – Superbowl vs the Champion’s League
Wikipedia – NFL
http://www.flickr.com/photos/nestorgalina/3707322819/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/zoutedrop/2317065892/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/artwork_rebel/2547734803/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/dok1/3901589403/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/virtualsugar/2055676442/
http://www.flickr.com/photos/johnbeagle/2839829019/
Personal – I was Raised on American Football
Personal – I started watching Football (Soccer) in ’97
Balls
Recent Comments